Song Reviews
Pure Americana Blues
The world renowned Plato once stated that 'Music is a moral law. It gives soul to the universe, wings to the mind, flight to the imagination, and charm and gaiety to life and to everything.' I ask the reader to keep in mind that Plato lived in time when the word 'gaiety' meant happiness and carefree-ness. And correct he was, for when I listened to this piece, my mind just sprouted wings and flew to new levels of mathematical and conceptual understanding previously unknown to man. Ole John Henry is in good company.
United States, Illinois, Chicago
Swingin'
Enjoyed listening to this swinging, catchy tune that has a cool little story line. Reminded me of some of the 'Squirrel Nut Zipper" tunes that I use to listen to. Thank you for the song. Cheers!
United States, Virginia
Manhatten Rob Walsh My Review!
Hey bro this is a really cool tune I like it and it is also cool to listen to good job on the vocals and the music was played well I think you have something here a lot of people will enjoy listening to keep up the good work I will be looking forward to also hearing more song from you from James Milligan President/CEO,New Experience Records/Universal Music Group.
United States, Mississippi, Marks
Good song
Interesting take on the theme and I like the retro sound. Some of the words are little bit hard to make out - place where it seemed like the music volume was higher than the vocal volume. Overall, though - I liked it.
United States, Idaho, Post Falls
Traditional blues roots
Reminds of the old blues ragtime with a modern sound good recording can hear instruments clearly Good story with lyrics vocals strong I could hear some soulful backing singing in the chorus would add some more colour though overall well done
Australia, Bridgetown
Fun Music
This song was a pleasant surprise. I don't think the recording or performance are at the professional level but about 80% there. The voice is confident and has some nice character. The music is fun and accompanies the song well. The song could use a little more polishing on the lyrics. But overall this is one of the better songs that I have had the pleasure of reviewing. Nice work Rob.
United States, California, Los Osos
Old time cool!
I really like this song, it has an authentic 'old time' feel and great lyrics. Well done Rob, simple and straightforward. Going to look up your other stuff and have a listen. Really enjoyed this, keep up the good work!
United Kingdom, Southport
Great recording!
New York City’s Manhattan Rob Walsh has recorded an outstanding tune entitled Don’t Tread on Me. The rhythm-section is fabulous and the horn arrangement/performance is second-to-none. Bravo!
United States, Washington, Seattle
Review of Don't Tread On Me
I'm enjoying listing to { Don't Tread On Me } as I'm drinking my coffee this afternoon. I fill that this song is a really well done. I really like this song and I would like to hearing more songs from the artist!
United States, Arkansas, Crossett
Storytelling artist
Rob tells a story using witty comparisons to well know phrases and characters. Some really nice clarinet playing through out. I would like to hear Rob sing this maybe one key higher as the low notes of his register get a bit gravelly but maybe that is the sound he is going for. Good concept and execution throughout. I enjoyed this song.
United States, New York, New York
No one's stepping on this one
Great sound on this one. A good intro followed by a great complementing vocal performance with the perfect vocal tone. There is one part where the vocal gets a little thin and could have used a few female vocals to help pull the song along. The I try part specifically. Otherwise this is a great song all around and a great tribute to that New Orleans jazz sound so many have come to love
United States, Illinois, Aurora
Awesome
I really like the song and I like your style it is catchy and later back you lyrics are crisp well composed and well put together keep on going and may God bless you in all that you go to do stay positive and true to you have a blessed day and a great hope this been helpful for you sir be blessed.
United States, California, Every Where
Old fashioned chicago style blues
This is a style that wouldn't look out of place in the streets of New Orleans and Chicago. Rich and a good old sound to the voice that suits the song really well.....but, do i line it or not? Well,I do.
United Kingdom, Coleraine
Great lyrics!
Love this style, kind of a Dixieland simplified. The lyrics evoke all the old American folk myths, throwing in zombies and modern day lethargy. You could draw resemblances to Tom Waits with the arrangements, but the voice is his own. Want to hear more!
United States, North Carolina, Greensboro
don't tread on me
old style Blues with a feelin' . . Reminds me of Leon Redbone . Great recording , vocals and band . I really like this song and don't mind recommending it to others . Hope you have great luck with this production , Cliff
United States, Kentucky, Louisville
a cool kind of dixieland
yeah buddy, i like this crazy kind of dixieland thing, the only thing that I would try to do might be get a little more excited and outragous when signing the vocal track its a little laid back, think if Dr John were to do it, with a taste of firewater. but still cool stuff
United States, Oklahoma, Tulsa
Talent shows
Although I do not care for this monotonous, depressing song which seems to go on forever, there can be no doubts that the singer has a natural singing talent and musical ability. In my opinion, he just needs the right song but I know that is not as easy as it sounds.
United Kingdom, Twickenham
Throw Back.
Wow! A cool throw back. And the horns are cool! I used to go hear a guy in The Village of East Davenport that sounded alot like Manhattan Rob. Good stuff! :) Of course , I'm from the land of Bix Biderbeck
United States, Illinois, QCs
Don't Tread on Me from Manhattan Rob Walsh
I enjoyed the song, it reminded me of a low voiced Cab Calloway with his big band. Sometimes, the words in the vocal line were hidden by the instruments. I believe a song should tell a story, and this song does, but hunting for the words hinders the story line. I especially like the clarinet and the low trombone. I know you'll keep writing and singing, because you've done this for a long time and obviously enjoy your craft. Good luck in the future.
United States, Washington, Bellevue
Bronx Bob
To be fair I'm not a big fan of the blues. This is probably a pretty good blues song though. I'm a folk guy and like the blues it's not really about the singing or music but about the lyrics, message, and mood. I think the lyrics here were very good and kept me engaged. The vocals and music were cookie cutter as far as I'm concerned and could be plugged into any other blues song. I listened to all your songs today and as I said your lyrics are your strong point in my opinion. One thing that really is just a side note is this sounds to me more like the Bronx or Harlem not Manhattan, with no disrespect to those areas. I know Manhattan is just part of your stage name but is kind of a disconnected to what you do, at least in the four songs I heard today. Maybe instead of Manhattan Rob, Bronx Bob. Just saying and I really do like your stuff~
United States, Ohio, Warren