I like the guitar riffs and the drums. Vocals are clear and the lead has a nice flow to the middle section! The melody is repetitive with vocals and lead following the same sequence! A middle 8 may help! But in general it’s and nice sound and good recording! The sound through my headphones was a little thin and so ask if the song compressed or mastered?

Hi, at the beginning your song is very engaging, it mentally takes me back to the 70s, on a trip on a cadillac on a long road, you really created an excellent felling. Congratulations also for the guitar solo, musically well structured. The only thing that could be improved is to lighten the Master sound and keep the vocals out by 1 or 2 db. The rest is fine. Very good.

Hello Richie! I like the intro, it's very catchy and encourages you to listen to more. I like the dissonant part too, because it's something you don't expect, I find it very particular and I think originality in music is the key. Not sure of how the voices have been recorded, they sound nice but the recording seems a bit old (or maybe it is?). The only critique (for my taste) is that I would add some vocals, maybe a refrain. Overall I've liked the song, the typical 70s - 80s sound... So good job :)

Carries the song well with the guitar on the upbeat strum, works really well. The vocal isn't out front very much, but that's ok, because it has a good partytime feel the lead guitar adds a good feel to it. good excitement behind it. Good work. Good luck with this happy sounding song!

From the begining the Guitar sound and the building up of the soung reminds me many 70's BIG Classic Bands. I liked how the mix have been done, nice equilibrium with all instruments in his place and with a good effect vnd sound selection. Sounds like a classic. Great work.

I like the lyrics and the rhytm of the tune but I think the song lacks a chorus. I think the song would be fun to play at a concert but it's not really ready for radio airplay as I hear it. Maybe with a better production it could catch on

When I listened to She Climbs a Vine .. it reminded me of good old get up and dance and have a good time... and let music free your soul... so get up and Dance !!!!! Time to DANCE .yes get up and dance and have a good time !

Hello, i will rate your song today ... Feedback for your music. The song is well structured .. Clear sound and clear voice ... I will gladly give you 4 stars for your song. I will listen to more of your songs. Musical greetings

Overall recording isn’t as bad as the song itself. Too simple. No hook. Not sure you got the lick exactly as you intended. Very dissonant overall. Just not my style. Keep on trying though, aim no musicccrtique!

Wow. Nice song. Sounds a bit stone-rocky ( comparable to e.g. Queens of the Stone Age). But you have a unique sound. Good guitars: The two guitars are really well tuned in on eachother. I especially like the chord-sequence/break that appears in the song: It's so nicely chaotic. Cool. Good solo. Lyrics are good. The composition of the song is a bit strange though; strange ending. Still: This is the second song I hear from you and I'm REALLY curious to hear more: This tune really got stuck in my head... Well done !

Richie Hoffman - She Climbs a Vine. This song has the sounds of drums and electric guitar, and constant beat with constant vocal sound, this is song is for people who love that rock band sound.

This is a song that obviously is influenced by the music of the 60's & 70's artists that rang across the airwaves and in our stereos. But your mix is off on both guitars and is that much more noticeable by separating them left & right. Bring them in a little toward center (10 and 2 o'clock perhaps?). They are also louder than your vocals and should be brought down a bit and the vocals brought up some. Good era sounding solo towards the end. It's an interesting composition that would benefit if you took it to a real studio and got it done professionally. A demo producer/engineer would give this song the jazz that I see you are trying to reach. Let me know if you redo this one. Good luck and keep writing!

good evening I just got three of you and your song Thank you for sharing it with me it's only very creative very special and unique will put together. Keep on going to the next level coupon prime music ever stop sharing thank you so much for sharing. I hope you having a wonderful weekend thanks for keeping in touch keep me posted on your music enjoy the rest your weekend and have a blessed day God bless.

Very good and well put together an organic sound which works well within the context of the tune, arrangement is sufficient and suits the song well very good musicianship not too intrusive

Very good elaborated alternative rock song. The intro of the two great accompanying e-guitars comes smooth and the drums including melodic bass-line puts one into the right mood. Imaginative transitions of the guitars aren´t really easy and make the song creative. The unique vocal projection from R. Hoffman brings more feeling into the song. The lyrics sounds like a story and make the meaning of the song engaging for me. The songwriter has the ability to give an account in words about someone or something and made this song special. Fantastic solo of the distortioned e-guitar in the middle make the music rich and brings increasing feel into the song. Brilliant song from a musician who understand what good music is about. Overall is this arrangement more creative than some others, influenced of melodic- and alternative rock music good recorded. This song is an original and I´m sure you will like add him. Let others know your recommendation.

Greetings, Thank you for choosing me to review your work, I count it an honor to be included in such a task. My hat is off to you and anyone willing to step out and share their gift, talent and love of music to the public. Be it a musician, singer, song writer, actor and so-on. I myself, via 40 some years of experience in the fields, on the road, in the studio, radio, TV, video, and management, consider myself to be a seasoned musician, singer, song writer, studio-sound tech/engineer/ owner/operator, stage manager, find it sometimes hard/difficult and perhaps not even fair to sit in a seat, voicing My Opinion concerning another's creative efforts. Especially in certain genres of music I am not all that familiar with concerning very important elements that make up and meet the required standards to justify the various levels of ratings and grades. So, in saying ALL that, I will limit myself to MY Opinion concerning the quality of the work according to My ears, and the standards I have been familiarized with thru-out the years. I hold to the old - saying " Beauty Is In The EAR of The Beholder ... LOL. The sound quality of the recording over-all is very crisp and bright and clear, I really enjoyed the energy in this song. Vocals are smooth. The mix levels let me know who was still in charge of this song. Very easy to sit back and listen to. I mean no offense in any part, I myself take all feedback and use it as a tool toward my next project. I pray you feel the same way. Either way, I say to you, keep doing what you do, keep kicking and enjoying what you do. I tell folks all the time for many years. When it stops being FUN, then it's time to stop, and stand back and think about what we are doing, why we are doing it, how we are doing it, what we and others are getting out it. Is it what we want, and how we want it. IF NOT. what are willing to do from there? Thank you again for asking MY OPINION. Johnny

This is a great song and performance. The melody is strong and tuneful. The singer has an attractive vocal tone, and puts real feeling into the lyrics. The lyrics are interesting and meaningful with some punchy phrases. Instrumentally, the song has a rich, full accompaniment that complements the vocal track perfectly. Great guitar solo too, although I think a grittier tone would suit the dark mood of the song better. The performance quality is high throughout, both vocally and instrumentally. Overall, the song is distinctive and original, and I think it has strong commercial potential.

This song has an interesting rhythm, it begins as a rock song, but the groove remembers more the grunge. Then it continues as hard rock, there's a particular style in your music and this is positive.